[12.02.26] Shinhwa “doesn’t play games with fans’ hearts”

Shinhwa’s emotional comeback – what are the 3 secrets to Shinhwa’s longevity?

People usually turn their eyes to instant glory rather than pure honesty. Just like how we go crazy over home runs rather than stolen bases and base hits.

But rather than a brilliant play of the moment, what truly touches our hearts is steadfast persistence. Like the sense of awe that Pete Rose of the Cincinnati Reds made the fans feel with his record 3,562nd game appearance. In this aspect, there are no idol groups in Korea with such moving persistence and honesty. Firstly they can’t be sustained for long.

Groundbreaking singing abilities for that day and age; the originator of Big Bang’s rotation system

In this sense, the comeback of ‘longevity idols’ Shinhwa, celebrating their 14th anniversary this year, is moving in itself. Because in Korea’s music scene, where countless idol groups have come and gone within short periods of time, they have demonstrated that ‘sustainable idols’ are a possibility. Given that idol groups like g.o.d, S.E.S, Fin.K.L – who made their debut around the same period – have already disbanded, one can tell by the long period of time that they have existed and the amount of love they have received from fans.

The reasons for their consistent popularity lie in the individual members’ excellent singing abilities and star qualities. One can say that these are basic or that these are generalizations but that’s not the case.

The fact that the members have solo-worthy singing abilities was something very groundbreaking back in those days. At that time, idol groups mostly passed musical duties to the lead vocalist with the singing ability. The member who could sing became the lead vocalist, while the member who couldn’t would become the rapper and sub-vocalist – it was a period when this was the norm.

As such, it was possible for Shinhwa to market themselves differently from other typical groups. The members individually released solo albums and participated in unit activities and eventually regrouped to release group albums. The rotation system in soccer was in implementation. Just like Big Bang now.

Their rotation strategy broke the longstanding industry standard of going on hiatus after album promotions concluded. Capitalizing on the voids left by other singers who were on hiatus, they began to gather more popularity. In fact the members all have released at least two solo albums. (note: not ALL actually – Eric hasn’t released anything remotely resembling an album yet 😦 ) Especially Shin Hyesung and Lee Minwoo who have released at least 6 albums each and have received much love.

At the same time, they made use of their variety skills and acting skills in their time outside of music activities to gain more popularity. Junjin became the 7th member of ‘Infinity Challenge’; Andy received rave reviews for ‘We Got Married’; Eric took on acting with a successful debut in 2004’s ‘Phoenix’, and went on to be the leading man of dramas such as ‘Super Rookie’ and ‘Spy Myungwol’.

Change of thinking in overcoming the disbandment crisis and ‘fandom’

If innovative marketing and the members’ outstanding abilities made Shinhwa what they are today, then the strong trust between Shinhwa and their fans is the secret to their longevity.

When their contract with their management company ended in 2003, the conflict between members who received renewal offers and members who didn’t, resulted in a disbandment crisis. In the moment of crisis, rather than to get hung up over the contents of the contraact, the 6 members all chose to move to a new management company.

After that they set up Shinhwa Company to continue Shinhwa’s group activities. This is a company set up to prevent the possible disbandment of the group when members sign up with different management companies after their contract with Good Entertainment ran out. Through this decision, they lived up to the promise they made to the fans who said that they’ll watch over Shinhwa. And they’ve earned the infinite trust from the fans, that no amount of money can buy.

Looking at Shinhwa returning after 4 years, attention will naturally fall on one area – the idol groups that have ambiguously halted their activities and are technically disbanded. The members all belong to different companies and are unlikely to reunite or show no signs of reuniting, but they refuse to officially declare their disbandment and refuse to let go of their fans.

The important basic of not playing with the fans’ hearts

Even though it may not be as many people as before, but there are still fans who love the group as a group. For the fans who love the group, watching the members in their individual activities can make them feel the cruel wait even more. To the fans who like the group and not the individual members, hope can be a torture.

In this sense, the implication of Shinhwa’s comeback is huge. Because it shows us how much stronger the relationship between the singer and the fans will become when a promise made with the fans is realized. Like how the food industry doesn’t mess with food, in the music industry it must be reminded that it’s a basic not to play games with fans’ hearts.

Credits: OhmyStar + Absolut Shinhwa

10 thoughts on “[12.02.26] Shinhwa “doesn’t play games with fans’ hearts”

  1. “the idol groups that have ambiguously halted their activities and are technically disbanded. The members all belong to different companies and are unlikely to reunite or show no signs of reuniting, but they refuse to officially declare their disbandment and refuse to let go of their fans”. – this is sooooooooo true.

    it’s like you are making hostage of your fans because you know that as a solo artist you are banking on the support of fans that is intended for the group. it’s like blackmail to me. you are giving false hope to fans. i’ve been hearing 2 or 3 groups saying we are not disbanded or we will reunite soon or we will release our group album after finishing solo activities. why can’t they admit that their group is over and move on. let the fans truthfuly decide wether the fan would like to support the solo artist or the group. at least be honest, even “technically” honest.

    shinhwa, the best! shinhwa changjo, the best!

  2. I love this article!! gives us hope that such great beautiful things are indeed more precious than any tangible thing in existence!! ♥

  3. the implication of Shinhwa’s comeback is huge. Because it shows us how much stronger the relationship between the singer and the fans will become when a promise made with the fans is realized.<<<<I really love this part .

    thanks for the translation sumi

  4. Thx for translating the article, Sumi. Concerning Eric who has no solo album yet, I believe he also wants it so bad, but for now the main priority for him and the rest of the guys is that concert on March 24, which coincides with a day before Easter, makes it a perfect Easter gift for me.

  5. Wow, this is a very good article. This makes me proud to be Shinhwa Changjo. Thanks Sumi for translating.

  6. It’s amazing fate they got these 6 together as a group… Their strong wills and determination is the force to keep them overcome all odds & adversities. Never regret being a fan

    probably not seeing that 5mil won album any time soon….
    timing not in his favor since discharge… more money saved for now XDDD

    1. Me too, I’ve started saving since last year, I hope it’s not too expensive. I think I can summarize the secret of Shinhwa’s long lasting journey with these words: persistence, hard work, tolerance that completes the talents they all have.

      1. Hope it won’t double, citing inflation XDDD

        Agree to all those words. I’ll add loyalty & ability to compromise. Also, their mentality of not thinking oneself higher/superior than another member really helps keep the group strong bond

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s